The newest revelation context while the standard concept of so it verse is maybe not, although not, with the question of relationships to non-Muslims. The fresh new traditional interpretation claims that the verse had been found whenever a few polytheist men out of Quraish requested the siblings is straight back, Oum Kelthoum and you can Bint Aqabah, after they got converted to Islam and migrated to help you Medina during the order to become listed on the Muslim area.
Which general tip isn’t necessarily genuine and “strength” and/or “weakness” of your religious faith isn’t associated with gender however, rather towards individuals character and you may reputation
It’s value reminding that Prophet closed during the time a contract called Al-Hudaybya Pact for the reverse group away from Quraish to eliminate the latest conflict to possess a decade. That it arrangement stipulated, yet others, one to one Quraychit woman who join the Prophet in Medina with no permission out-of the lady legal tutor are sent back to Mecca.
Oum Kelthoum, who had been alone to convert to Islam in her family unit members, and which fled from 1 really hostile surroundings, begged the brand new Prophet not to ever repatriate the girl to the woman group very while the never to feel exposed once again to their unfair treatment.
The latest verse previously mentioned ended up being shown to avoid the new extradition of women whom converted to Islam and avoid brand new revenge off their particular group. For this reason, the Prophet refused to publish straight back the fresh new exiled lady for the opponents, since agreement are handled for males.
The explanation of one’s verse above mentioned suggests that it does perhaps not tackle at all the marriage so you can non-Muslims, however, try alternatively revealed to satisfy certain proper conditions out of securing women that transformed into Islam up against the commonly of its members of the family and you may whom voluntarily wanted the fresh Prophet’s safeguards.
The fresh paradox that individuals stress throughout these classical interpretations issues the brand new proven fact that according to these types of students, Muslim ladies are prohibited to help you wed “disbelievers” in addition to Christian and Jewish guys, when you are for the question of Muslim boys, Religious and Jewish women are thought to be believers. How can we envision, in the same Religious otherwise Jewish community, you to guys are disbelievers whenever you are females of the identical teams try believers?
Regarding the absence of any evidence that justifies the ban of the wedding off Muslim girls for the supporters out of almost every other monotheistic religions, the fresh new latest scholars justify the thinking by “the brand new sheer exhaustion” out-of Muslim women who might go astray according to the “bad” dictate of their Christian otherwise Jewish husbands. Nevertheless Muslim guy might be able to take over his Religious or Jewish partner and cover their kid’s and you may individual trust.
The new Qur’anic verse, tackling the wedding away from Muslim men or women in order to believers off almost every other religions, lay certain regulations playing with an enthusiastic egalitarian vocabulary
Indeed, the fresh dispute isn’t convincing as if the newest said verse forbids the marriage between an effective Muslim woman and you can an excellent Religious otherwise Jewish guy as it is unanimously interpreted today, therefore instance matrimony is additionally taboo to the Muslim boy. Still, considering certain Qur’anic passages additionally the Islamic integrity, Christians and you can Jews are believed unanimously since believers owned by religions shown because of the Allah long lasting present variations in regards to brand new dogma therefore the theological opinions.
Because of this, the research regarding the verse means that new Qur’an prohibits the newest relationships from both Muslim individuals polytheists.
But it’s worth discussing you to definitely scholars agree unanimously to the ban of your relationship out of a Muslim woman in order to a Jewish otherwise Religious, when you are zero a portion of the Qur’an provides for such as prohibition one to warrants so it discrimination.